St. Marys home value

What’s my home worth in St. Marys?

Three quick questions, then we reply by email. What you share stays private, and there’s no obligation.

  1. We’ll email you back to learn a little more about the home.
  2. We look at recent sales nearby and what’s on the market now.
  3. You get our honest opinion of value, with the reasons behind it.

Step 1 of 3 What kind of home is it?

It points us to the right nearby sales. Just a street or a neighbourhood is enough.

Step 2 of 3 When might you sell?
Step 3 of 3 How can we reach you?

Either email or phone is fine; we only need one.

Your note comes straight to Tanner. Nothing gets booked before we’ve spoken.

What is your home worth? How we work it out

  1. Recent sales nearby

    We look at homes like yours that have sold close by, and how long they took to sell.

  2. What’s for sale now

    The homes a buyer will compare with yours this month matter as much as last year’s sales.

  3. Your home itself

    The lot, the layout, the updates, and the setting. We’ll ask about the things a listing photo can’t show.

Online estimates can’t see inside your home, and with one-of-a-kind homes there are often too few similar sales for a formula to work well. That’s why we give you a price with our reasoning, not just a number.

We give opinions of value across St. Marys, including Downtown and Queen Street, The Quarry and the south end, and The east ward. See the questions sellers ask us and how we sell every type of home.

Home prices in St. Marys by type of home

The MLS® Home Price Index tracks the price of a typical home rather than whatever happened to sell that month. For October 2026, it put these benchmarks on Huron and Perth counties:

MLS® HPI benchmarks, October 2026, Huron and Perth counties
Type of homeBenchmark price
A typical home (composite)$537,800
Single-family home$544,900
Apartment$404,200

A benchmark describes a typical home across a whole board area, so a home in St. Marys can sit well above or below it. Yours is priced from the sales closest to it.

Sources: Canadian Real Estate Association, MLS® Home Price Index data, October 2026; cross-checked against an independent market report for October 2026.

Homes across St. Marys

Each part of St. Marys has its own mix of homes, and buyers compare yours with the ones around it. From our St. Marys guide:

  1. Downtown and Queen Street

    Stone and brick homes from the 1800s on the streets around Queen Street.

    Downtown runs along Queen Street, with limestone commercial blocks, the town hall, and the library on Church Street North.

  2. The Quarry and the south end

    Older homes near the river and the museum, with more modern streets further south.

    South of downtown, the Riverview Walkway follows the Thames, Centennial Park and the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame are close to the river, with the swimming quarry just beyond.

  3. The east ward

    Homes of many ages, with family streets near the schools and the recreation centre.

    East of downtown, St. Marys District Collegiate and Vocational Institute is on Elizabeth Street, and the Pyramid Recreation Centre, Little Falls Public School, and Solis Fields sit together further east.

  4. The west ward and the north end

    Older stone and brick homes near downtown, and homes of many ages further out.

    West of the river, Queen Street West leads past St. Marys Memorial Hospital and West Ward Park.

Nearby: Stratford home values, London home values, and Exeter home values.

Opinion of value, appraisal, or MPAC assessment?

Three different numbers can be attached to a home in St. Marys, and they answer different questions.

How an opinion of value, an appraisal, and an MPAC assessment differ
Opinion of valueAppraisalMPAC assessment
Who prepares itUs, as your REALTORS®A licensed appraiserMPAC, the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation
What it’s forSetting a listing price and a plan to sellA formal report, often ordered by a lenderYour property tax bill
What it looks atRecent sales nearby, what’s for sale now, and your home itselfThe home and comparable sales, in a formal written reportValues as of January 1, 2016, for every property in Ontario

So an assessment that looks low, or an online figure that looks high, doesn’t tell you what a buyer in St. Marys will pay this month.

St. Marys

Questions sellers ask us

How much is my house worth in St. Marys?

It depends on your home, the recent sales near you, and what’s for sale now. A benchmark or an average describes the market, not your home, so we look at yours and give you a price with our reasoning.

Is the opinion of value free?

Yes. It’s free, and asking for it doesn’t commit you to anything. Fill in three short questions and we’ll write back.

How is this different from an online estimate or an appraisal?

An online estimate works from public records and can’t see inside your home. An appraisal is a formal report from a licensed appraiser, often ordered by a lender. Our opinion of value is our reasoned estimate of a listing price, with the sales we compared and why. It’s an estimate, not an appraisal.

Nearby home values: London, Stratford, Exeter, Woodstock, Plattsville. Or see every place we work.

Read more about pricing: how we price a home, and why it can differ from an online estimate.

Book a conversation