How to choose a listing price

The price you list at shapes who comes to see your home, how quickly offers arrive, and how strong they are. Here’s how we work it out with you, and what we watch after the sign goes up.

By Tanner Hickey and Robin Hickey, RE/MAX Real Estate Centre Inc., Brokerage. Updated November 20, 2026.

The short answer

Price your home where today’s buyers can see its value next to the homes they’re comparing it with. That starts with recent sales of truly similar homes nearby, adjusted for what makes yours different, and then checked against what’s for sale right now, because that’s your real competition.

A list price isn’t a promise of what a home will sell for, and it isn’t a wish. It’s a decision you make with the clearest evidence available, and you can change it.

What we look at

We start with sold prices, not asking prices. A home that sold last month tells you what a buyer actually paid; a home sitting unsold for months tells you where buyers wouldn’t go.

  • Recent sales nearby: the closest true matches in size, age, lot, and layout, ideally on the same streets and within the last few months.
  • What’s for sale now: the homes your buyers will see the same weekend. If three similar homes are listed below you, buyers will notice.
  • Listings that didn’t sell: expired and withdrawn listings often show a price the market wouldn’t accept.
  • Your home itself: condition, updates, parking, the lot, the light, and the street. These are things no online estimate can see.
  • The pace of the market: how long homes are taking to sell and how many months of supply there are. Our monthly market report tracks this for each board.

Board benchmark and average prices describe a whole market, not your home. They’re useful for direction, and we show them in the market report, but we never price a home from them alone.

Choosing a pricing approach

Most homes are well served by a price close to where the evidence points. It invites the buyers who are already looking in that range, and it leaves room for a fair negotiation.

Some sellers choose to list below market value and set an offer date, hoping several buyers compete. That can work when demand is strong and the home stands out, but it isn’t a sure thing. If fewer buyers show up than you hoped, you may face a decision about an offer below what you wanted. You’re never required to accept an offer, and we’ll talk through the risks honestly before you choose.

In Ontario, if more than one written offer arrives, every buyer who made one is entitled to know how many competing offers there are. Whether anything more is shared is your decision, and your agent can only share an offer’s contents with your written direction.

Sources: Real Estate Council of Ontario, Dealing with competing offers (for sellers); Real Estate Council of Ontario, Competing offers (for buyers); Ontario Regulation 357/22 under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2002.

Why pricing too high costs more than it seems

Buyers and their agents watch new listings closely in the first days. A home priced above the evidence tends to be skipped by the very buyers it was meant for, because it shows up in the wrong searches and looks weak beside its neighbours.

The longer a home sits, the more buyers wonder what’s wrong with it, and the more leverage they feel they have. A price change later can work, but it rarely recovers the attention a home gets when it’s new. Getting it close at the start is usually kinder to your timeline and your final price.

What we watch once you’re on the market

Showings, second showings, feedback from buyers’ agents, and how many people ask about the home tell us early whether the price is landing. If the first week or two is slow while similar homes are selling, we’ll show you the evidence and talk about whether to adjust. If it’s busy, we’ll talk about how to handle interest from more than one buyer.

If you’d like a starting point, ask for a free opinion of value. It’s our reasoned estimate with the sales we compared, not an appraisal. Our answers on pricing go further.

How to choose a listing price

Questions people ask us

How do you decide what to list a home for?

We start with recent sales of the most similar homes nearby, adjust for the differences, and check the result against what’s for sale now. Then we look at how quickly homes are selling. You make the final decision with that evidence in front of you.

Is it better to price low and hope for a bidding war?

Not always. It can work when demand is strong and the home stands out, but if fewer buyers compete than you hoped, you may be weighing an offer below what you wanted. You’re never required to accept an offer. We’ll talk through the risks before you choose.

Why not start high and come down later?

A home is seen by the most buyers in its first days. Priced above the evidence, it shows up in the wrong searches and looks weak beside similar homes. A later reduction rarely brings back that first wave of attention.

Can we see the sales you used?

Yes. Our opinion of value shows the sales we compared and why, so you can see the reasoning, not just a number.

Book a conversation

Still choosing an agent? Read how to choose a realtor.

Next step

A private conversation

The simplest next step is a short conversation, at your home, at our Cambridge office, or by phone. Tell us what you’re considering and we’ll tell you honestly what we’d do. There’s no obligation.